SAINTS.APP Saint
All saints

c. 769-840·Feast June 6

St. Agobard

Archbishop of Lyon

Portrait of St. Agobard
Friedrich Hottenroth·Public domain

Born Spain·🇫🇷 France

Overview

Agobard of Lyon — a Spain-born priest, alive from about 769 until 840 — held the see of Lyon as archbishop in the Carolingian Renaissance, writing prolifically on subjects from the iconoclast controversy and Spanish Adoptionism to his critiques of the Carolingian royal house, and is remembered today chiefly for polemics aimed at Jewish religious practice and at Jewish political standing within the Frankish realm. He came to Lyon in 792, was ordained priest around 804, and was well liked by Archbishop Leidrad, under whom he served as chorbishop. When Leidrad retired into a monastery in 814 and appointed Agobard his successor, other bishops protested at a synod at Arles against consecrating a new bishop while the old still lived; Leidrad's death in 816 ended the dispute and left Agobard archbishop. In office he opposed trials by ordeal, wrote in 818 against Felix of Urgel's Adoptionist Christology, and in the 820s entered the long, notorious campaign of anti-Jewish polemic for which his memory is most contested: from De Baptismo Judaicorum Mancipiorum (c. 823) through Contra Praeceptum Impium, De Insolentia Judeorum, De Judaicis Superstitionibus, and De Cavendo Convictu et Societate Judaica (c. 826-827), he attacked the protections Louis the Pious had granted Jewish communities — rhetoric, among it the labeling of Jews as 'children of the devil,' that nourished the emerging anti-Jewish current of medieval Christian thought. When political crisis gripped the reign he sided with Lothair I's rebellions against Louis in 830 and 833; after Louis's restoration Agobard was suspended by the Council of Thionville and exiled, his see given to Amalarius of Metz, until Louis's death in 840 allowed his return. He died that same year and was succeeded by Amulo. His treatise against trial by ordeal, and his refusal of superstition, mark the better side of a difficult, formidable mind.

The Complete Life

From Spain to Lyon

Agobard was a native of Spain, born around 769 — probably in the Pyrenean region from which so many churchmen crossed into the Frankish realm in the age of Charlemagne. He moved to Lyon in 792, was ordained priest around 804, and won the favor of Leidrad, the archbishop of Lyon (799-816), one of the scholars Charlemagne appointed to reform the Gallic church. At some point Agobard was ordained chorbishop, a kind of assistant bishop — and when Leidrad, now old, withdrew to monastic life in 814 and named Agobard to succeed him, the elevation provoked a synod at Arles, where bishops protested the consecration of a new bishop while the old still lived. Leidrad died in 816; the controversy fizzled; Agobard became archbishop of Lyon.

§ Early life

Archbishop, Reformer, Polemicist

Agobard's episcopate was an almost continuous engagement with the issues of the Carolingian church. He opposed trials by ordeal, one of the earliest and most principled attacks on the practice. In 818 he wrote against Felix of Urgel's Spanish Adoptionism, the Christology that had drawn Spanish Christianity into controversy with the Frankish church. In the 820s he entered the iconoclastic debate provoked by Claudius of Turin, opposing in his Book on Paintings and Images not the veneration of images but Dungal of Bobbio's method of justifying it by secular learning — Agobard's own taste in theology ran to the literal and the patristic. He was, in all this, a working metropolitan: preaching, legislating, corresponding, and governing the greatest see of Burgundy.

§ Icons

The Anti-Jewish Polemic

The notoriety of Agobard's loud assaults on the Frankish realm's Jewish communities endures. Louis the Pious had granted those communities considerable freedoms — appointing a magister Iudaeorum to ensure their legal protection, prohibiting Christian proselytizing among them, and refusing to force the baptism of their slaves. Agobard found this last provision galling, and from c. 823, with De Baptismo Judaicorum Mancipiorum, he spent the rest of that decade campaigning against what he judged a perilous rise of Jewish influence at odds with canon law, in works including Contra Praeceptum Impium, De Insolentia Judeorum, De Judaicis Superstitionibus, and De Cavendo Convictu et Societate Judaica. Such rhetoric — filii diaboli, children of the devil, was his name for the Jews — nourished the emerging anti-Jewish current of medieval Christian thought. Jeremy Cohen, the historian, observed that Agobard's polemic was paradoxically both learned and stereotyped: he knew a great deal about contemporary Judaism and used it to perpetuate the old calumnies. No account of Agobard's sanctity can pass over this record in silence.

§ Anti-Jewish polemic

Rebellion, Exile, Return

Agobard was no courtier. In the 820s he confronted Louis the Pious over the Jews and over church lands in secular hands; in the 830s he accused the emperor of abandoning the Ordinatio imperii of 817, the blueprint of unity of church and empire that Agobard — with his whole-hearted theology of a single Christian commonwealth — held sacred. In both the rebellions of 830 and 833 he supported the ill-fated revolt of Louis's son Lothair I, and in 833 he wrote two works in the rebels' defense — A Comparison of Ecclesiastical and Political Government, its full title continuing Wherein the Dignity of the Church Outshines the Majesty of Empires — together with the Liber Apologeticus. When Louis regained power, sustained by Louis the German and Pepin I, Agobard was suspended by the Council of Thionville and exiled; the chorbishop Amalarius of Metz replaced him and imposed allegorizing liturgical reforms that Agobard, when restored after Louis's death in 840, despised. He returned to Lyon and died that same year, succeeded by Amulo, his own choice and a continuator of his policies.

§ Political problems

Veneration

Agobard is a pre-congregation saint of the church of Lyon, where his cult was local and his feast kept on 6 June. The church that honors him honors a difficult man: a champion of legal rationality against the ordeal, a critic of superstition, a theorist of the unity of Christendom, and an author of texts that did real harm to the Jews of his own and later ages. His memory is kept both for what he fought and for what he fought against.

§ Introduction

Legacy

Agobard's legacy is double, and honesty requires both sides. Historically he is one of the major sources for the religious and political history of the Carolingian empire: his treatises document the Adoptionist controversy, the iconoclast dispute in the West, the Jewish policy of Louis the Pious, the theory of empire, and the liturgical wars — with an irascible clarity that makes him indispensable. Morally he embodies both the best of the Carolingian church — its opposition to ordeal and superstition, its ideal of a law-governed Christian society — and one of its worst legacies, the learned anti-Judaism that medieval Europe would turn to catastrophe. He remains a saint to study with open eyes.

§ Anti-Jewish polemic

Timeline

The Record

Major works
De Baptismo Judaicorum Mancipiorum·Contra Praeceptum Impium·De Insolentia Judeorum·De Judaicis Superstitionibus·De Cavendo Convictu et Societate Judaica·Liber Apologeticus·Book on Paintings and Images
Symbols
Archbishop's pallium·Writer's desk and books
Canonization
Pre-congregation; local cult at Lyon

Prayer

St. Agobard, scholar-bishop of Lyon, your learning served the church in an age of empire, and some of your battles were holy and some were not. Pray for the church of Lyon, for theologians, and for us: give us your courage against injustice and superstition, and save us from the zeal that wounds the innocent. Through Christ our Lord. Amen.

Bibliography

Show 12 sources
  1. ↑ Jones, Terry. "Agobard" . Patron Saints Index . Archived from the original on 9 February 2007 . Retrieved 2007-03-18 .
  2. ↑ For example, Adversus legem Gundobadi (PL:104:113B-126B) and Contra judicium Dei (PL 104: 249C- 287C).
  3. ↑ Against the Dogma of Felix: Adversus dogma Felicis Urgellensis PL:104:29C-70A.
  4. ↑ PL 104:99D-106B
  5. ↑ Allen Cabaniss, Agobard of Lyons: Churchman and Critic , (Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press, 1953), 46–7.
  6. ↑ PL 104:173D-178C
  7. ↑ PL 104:69B-76B
  8. ↑ PL 104:77A-100C
  9. ↑ PL 104:107A-114B
  10. ↑ McCracken, Early Medieval Theology , 329.
  11. ↑ Jeremy Cohen, Living Letters of the Law: Ideas of the Jew in Medieval Christianity , (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1999), 144–5.
  12. ↑ S. Wemple, "Claudius of Turin's Organic Metaphor or the Carolingian Doctrine of Incorporation," Speculum 49 (1974): 222–37; James R. Ginther, Westminster Handbook to Medieval Theology, (Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox Press, 2009),

Profile text adapted from the Wikipedia article, licensed CC BY-SA 4.0.

Pray with this saint every day

Save St. Agobard to your favorites, read the full profile, and get feast-day reminders in the Saints app.

Get the Saints App

Free on the App Store for iPhone and iPad

SAINTS.APP Profile of St. Agobard

CosmoLabs