died 599·Feast April 21
St. Anastasius I of Antioch
Patriarch of Antioch, Confessor
Overview
Anastasius I was Patriarch of Antioch twice, from 561 to 571 and again from 593 to 599; in Alban Butler's judgment he was a man of rare learning and piety. Friendly with Pope Gregory I, he drew the enmity of the Emperor Justinian by standing against certain imperial doctrines concerning the Body of Christ, since Justinian leaned toward the Aphthartodocetist teaching that Christ's body was incorruptible before the resurrection. Anastasius was to have been deposed and exiled when Justinian died in 565; but five years afterwards, in 570, Justin II executed his uncle's design, and Gregory of Antioch took his place. When Gregory died in 593, Anastasius was restored, chiefly through the intercession of Gregory the Great with the emperor Maurice. The pope's letters to him also hint that Anastasius was not vigorous enough in resisting the patriarch of Constantinople's claim to be universal bishop. He died in 599 — Theophanes records a horrible death at the hands of the Antiochene Jews during an uprising, though the sources conflict and some distinguish a second Anastasius who suffered in that tumult.
The Complete Life
Early Life and First Patriarchate
Almost nothing is recorded of Anastasius before his enthronement as Patriarch of Antioch in 561, succeeding Domnus III on the throne of the apostles Peter and Paul. Butler's verdict on his character — singular learning and piety — is the summary tradition preserved of him. His first years as patriarch fell in the long dusk of Justinian's reign, when the emperor's theological meddling kept the eastern sees in turmoil; Antioch, still Chalcedonian after the miaphysite exodus, needed a bishop who could hold the imperial court at arm's length. Anastasius proved willing to do so. He was also, by the time of his second tenure, a correspondent and friend of Gregory the Great, the newly-elected bishop of Rome, in an exchange that shows the networks of friendship holding the divided sixth-century church together across the Mediterranean.
Conflict with Justinian
The crisis of Anastasius' first patriarchate was doctrinal. Justinian, in his last years, favoured the Aphthartodocetae — partisans of the notion that Christ's humanity, being inseparable from his divinity, was incorruptible and incapable of suffering before the passion — and sought to impose a formula on the church. Anastasius opposed these imperial doctrines concerning the Body of Christ, refusing to make the emperor's speculation the price of peace. Justinian determined to depose and exile him, but death overtook the emperor in 565 before the sentence was executed. The reprieve lasted five years: Justin II carried out his uncle's purpose around 570, and Anastasius was removed from his see, with Gregory of Antioch set in his place. For two decades the confessor patriarch lived in displacement while another man sat in his chair, a quiet witness against the principle that theology can be legislated.
Restoration and Death
When Gregory died in 593, the throne of Antioch was restored to Anastasius, and the restoration owed much to Rome: Gregory the Great interceded with the emperor Maurice and his son Theodosius, asking that, if Anastasius were not reinstated at Antioch, he at least be sent to Rome. The emperor yielded the more. In his second tenure Anastasius received the pope's letters, including one gently chiding him for insufficient vigour in denouncing the patriarch of Constantinople's claim to be universal bishop — evidence both of the rivalry brewing between old and new Romes and of the respect in which Anastasius' judgment was held. He died in 599. Theophanes recounts that he was killed in an uprising of the Jews of Antioch, disembowelled and forced to eat his own intestines, a ghastly and debated notice: others place his death in 598 and attribute the killing to a successor of the same name, though Nicephorus insists the two were one.
Legacy
Anastasius stands for the patriarch as confessor in the age of caesaropapism: twice placed on the throne of Antioch, twice a lesson in the distinction between the emperor's will and the Church's faith. His friendship with Gregory the Great links him to the greatest pope of his century, and his failure to resist Byzantine pretensions vigorously enough — the gentle criticism of the letters — makes him humanly credible. The confusion of the sources about his death and about the Sermones de orthodoxa fide variously ascribed to him and to Anastasius II kept scholars busy from Nicephorus to the Bollandists; the festal day of 21 April in the Roman Martyrology preserves his cult. For the church of Antioch, in every communion, he remains a father who paid for the faith of the incarnation with his throne.
Timeline
- 561
Installed as Patriarch of Antioch, succeeding Domnus III, in the first of his two tenures
§ Introduction
- 570
Deposed and exiled when Emperor Justin II executed Justinian's plan; Gregory of Antioch took his place
§ Introduction
- 593
Restored to the see of Antioch after Gregory's death, chiefly through Pope Gregory the Great's intercession
§ Introduction
- 599
Died at Antioch; Theophanes records he was killed by Jews of the city during an uprising, though sources conflict
§ Introduction
The Record
- Major works
- Sermones de orthodoxa fide (attribution disputed)·Translation of Gregory the Great's Regula Pastoralis (attributed)
- Patron of
- Antioch
- Symbols
- Patriarchal vestments·Gospel book
- Canonization
- Pre-congregation
Prayer
Profile text adapted from the Wikipedia article, licensed CC BY-SA 4.0.
Pray with this saint every day
Save St. Anastasius I of Antioch to your favorites, read the full profile, and get feast-day reminders in the Saints app.
Get the Saints AppFree on the App Store for iPhone and iPad