before 324-405·Feast October 11 (Eastern Orthodox)
St. Arsacius of Tarsus
Archbishop of Constantinople (contested)
Overview
Arsacius of Tarsus, born before 324, intruded into the archbishopric of Constantinople from 404 to 405, set on the throne after John Chrysostom's violent expulsion. Nectarius of Constantinople, Chrysostom's predecessor, was his brother, and he had served as archpresbyter under Chrysostom. That brother had once marked him out for the bishopric of Tarsus; his refusal was attributed by some to an ambitious design of succeeding Nectarius at Constantinople, and Palladius of Galatia asserts that Arsacius voluntarily swore he would never accept that see. By the time he was roughly eighty, the intrigue of Empress Aelia Eudoxia and Theophilus of Alexandria against Chrysostom had succeeded, and the throne lay unexpectedly open; the intriguers wanted a man they could control, and Arsacius — whose hostility to Chrysostom had been testified at the synod of the Oak, where he appeared as a witness against him — met the requirement. His consecration fell on 27 June 404; from exile Chrysostom branded him a spiritual adulterer, a wolf in sheep's clothing. Constantinople's people, almost to a man, declined to attend his services and gathered instead outside the city, until soldiers dispersed the assemblies and a fierce persecution of Chrysostom's adherents began — cruelties for which, Sozomen records, Arsacius was not personally responsible, but which he lacked the strength of character to oppose. The Western episcopate refused to acknowledge him; Pope Innocent I wrote to Constantinople condemning the intrusion. His position intolerable and his health broken, Arsacius died on 11 November 405. The Eastern Church nevertheless venerates him as a saint on 11 October, a commemoration attested from the first millennium.
The Complete Life
Brother of Nectarius
Arsacius was born before 324, the brother of Nectarius, the senator who became bishop of Constantinople in 381 and predecessor of John Chrysostom. Arsacius served as archpresbyter under Chrysostom — the senior priest of the cathedral — and in his earlier years his brother had marked him out for the bishopric of Tarsus. That he declined it was attributed, by those unsympathetic to him, to an ambitious design of succeeding Nectarius at Constantinople; Palladius of Galatia, Chrysostom's biographer, asserts that Arsacius voluntarily swore never to accept that see — a oath the event would make famous.
§ Biography
The Intrusion
In 404 the intrigue of the empress Aelia Eudoxia and Theophilus of Alexandria against Chrysostom succeeded: the great preacher was violently expelled. What the victors wanted was an archbishop under their thumb, whose authority could lend cover to their plot, and Arsacius — about eighty, compliant, and demonstrably hostile to Chrysostom since his testimony at the synod of the Oak in 403 — met the requirements. He was consecrated on 27 June 404. Chrysostom, hearing of it from exile, branded him a spiritual adulterer, a wolf in sheep's clothing. The diocese's own verdict was plain: apart from court officials and those hoping for royal favor, people stayed away from any service at which he might preside, leaving the churches to assemble on the outskirts and under the open sky. Troops broke up those gatherings; their leaders were seized and tortured, and a fierce persecution of those attached to Chrysostom got under way. Sozomen states that Arsacius was not personally responsible for the cruel deeds but lacked the strength of character to offer decided opposition to his clergy: they did as they pleased, and Arsacius bore the blame.
§ Biography
Collapse of the Episcopate
On 10 November 404 the bishops and clergy who would not recognize Arsacius were driven from the East — an uprooting that only widened the schism. Not one bishop of the West would acknowledge him, and Pope Innocent I — a warm supporter of Chrysostom's cause — wrote to clergy and laity alike in Constantinople to condemn the intrusion and urge them to stand by their lawful archbishop. Arsacius's position became intolerable; worn out by old age before the storm of universal opposition, he died on 11 November 405, after eighteen months on the throne. He was succeeded by Atticus, and Chrysostom's own cause was vindicated within a generation.
§ Biography
A Contested Veneration
In the Eastern Orthodox Church Arsacius is kept as a saint on 11 October — 24 October on the New Style calendar — a commemoration attested from the first millennium — he is named in the Byzantine synaxaria with Nectarius and Sisinnius, patriarchs of Constantinople, and appears in the Typicon of the Great Church. Western tradition, following Palladius, Innocent I, and the historians, has never ceased to call him the intruder. The divergence is itself instructive: the church's calendars preserve memory with less argument than its historians, and a man condemned in the documents of his own day has a feast day in the East sixteen centuries later.
§ Attribution
Legacy
Arsacius's legacy is a caution. He is remembered as the counter-example to Chrysostom — the aged, acquiescent prelate installed by an empress's plot over the protests of a whole people — and his episcopate of eighteen months is one of the shortest and saddest in the history of Constantinople. Sozomen's verdict is the gentlest and probably the truest: not personally cruel, but too weak to stop the cruel, and so the bearer of their blame. In the study of the Chrysostom controversy he is a standing lesson in what the church suffers when its leadership is chosen for its manageability.
§ Biography
Timeline
- 324
Born before this year; brother of Nectarius, later archbishop of Constantinople
§ Introduction
- 27 Jun 404
Consecrated archbishop of Constantinople at about eighty years of age, after John Chrysostom's expulsion
§ Biography
- 18 Nov 404
Bishops and clergy embracing Chrysostom's cause are driven out of the East for refusing to recognize him
§ Biography
- 11 Nov 405
Dies after a brief episcopate worn down by universal opposition to his intrusion
§ Biography
The Record
- Symbols
- Episcopal vestments·The throne of Constantinople
- Canonization
- Venerated in the Eastern Orthodox Church on 11 October; a contested figure in Western tradition
Prayer
Bibliography
Show 10 sources
- ↑ Venables 1911 cites ( Photius I C. 59)
- ↑ Venables 1911 cites Palladius c. xi.
- 1 2 3 4 Venables 1911 .
- ↑ Venables 1911 cites Ep. cxxv.
- ↑ "Arsacius", Ecumenical Patriarchate of Constantinople
- ↑ Venables 1911 cites Sozomen, H. E. , VIII, 23
- ↑ Venables 1911 Sozomen, H. E., vi, 22, 26.
- ↑ "Orthodox Calendar - Old Style, 11 October; New Style, 24 October" . orthochristian.com . Archived from the original on 9 May 2023 . Retrieved 13 December 2024 .
- ↑ "Οἱ Ἅγιοι Νεκτάριος, Ἀρσάκιος καὶ Σισίνιος Πατριάρχες Κωνσταντινουπόλεως" . ΜΕΓΑΣ ΣΥΝΑΞΑΡΙΣΤΗΣ (in Greek). Archived from the original on 1 December 2023 . Retrieved 14 December 2024 .
- ↑ Mateos, Juan, ed. (1962). Le Typicon de la Grande Église (in Ancient Greek and French). Vol. 1. Rome: Pontifical Oriental Institute . pp. 66– 67.
Profile text adapted from the Wikipedia article, licensed CC BY-SA 4.0.
Pray with this saint every day
Save St. Arsacius of Tarsus to your favorites, read the full profile, and get feast-day reminders in the Saints app.
Get the Saints AppFree on the App Store for iPhone and iPad