died 518·Feast July 20
St. Flavian II of Antioch
Deposed Patriarch of Antioch and Confessor of Chalcedon
Overview
Flavian II governed the patriarchate of Antioch from 498 until his deposition and banishment in 512, dying in exile in 518. A monk formed in the rule of St. Basil at the monastery of Tilmognon, he had served as apocrisiarius before Emperor Anastasius I raised him to the see of Antioch on the death of Patriarch Palladius, on condition that he accept the Henotikon, the imperial formula of reunion between the Chalcedonian and non-Chalcedonian parties. As patriarch he joined Elias of Jerusalem in resisting attempts to abolish the Council of Chalcedon, yet strove to hold a middle course between the factions of a divided city; in 508 or 509 the emperor compelled him to sign the Henotikon. Philoxenus of Mabbug accused him of Nestorianism, and in 511 the bishop of Hierapolis stirred the Miaphysites of the Syrian countryside to march on Antioch and force a condemnation of Chalcedon. The attackers were met and slaughtered by the city's Chalcedonians, their bodies thrown into the Orontes, while the monks of Flavian's old monastery came to the city in his defense. The violence pushed Anastasius toward a Miaphysite policy, and in 512 a synod convened at Sidon by Philoxenus and eighty bishops deposed Flavian and Elias. Flavian was sent into exile at Petra, dying there in 518; his fall fed the rebellion of Vitalian in 513, and he was soon counted among the saints of the East, and afterwards of the West.
The Complete Life
A Basilian Monk in the Imperial Service
Before Antioch knew him, Flavian had been formed in two of the great institutions of the Eastern empire: the monastery and the diplomatic service. He was a monk under the rule of St. Basil at the monastery of Tilmognon, a house whose discipline shaped the ascetic character the sources would later praise, and from monastic life he passed into the office of apocrisiarius — the resident representative who conducted a church's business with the imperial court. The combination was a familiar ladder in the late fifth century, when emperors increasingly preferred to promote men of monastic reputation to high sees, expecting that their ascetic prestige would calm the doctrinal passions of the cities. Anastasius I, who occupied the throne from 491, needed exactly such a man for Antioch, the most turbulent patriarchate in his realm, where the settlement of Chalcedon was hated by much of the population and defended by the remainder. When Patriarch Palladius died in 498, the emperor chose the monk of Tilmognon as his successor, but on an explicit condition: that he accept the Henotikon, the compromise formula issued by Zeno, which had sought to reconcile the parties by silence on the two natures. Flavian accepted, and took the throne bound to a policy he would strain against for fourteen years.
§ Biography
Patriarch Between Two Fires
Once installed, Flavian revealed a loyalty to Chalcedon that his promise to the emperor had been meant to exclude. Together with Elias, the patriarch of Jerusalem, he resisted the attempts, persistent through the reign of Anastasius, to have the Council of Chalcedon abolished altogether. Yet Antioch itself was split, and the patriarch who ruled only one party would soon lose the city; Flavian therefore endeavored to please both sides by steering a middle course on the decrees of the council — affirming its faith while avoiding its vocabulary where it inflamed. It was a policy of survival, and it could not last. In 508 or 509 Anastasius forced him to sign the Henotikon formally, a humiliation that bought time and satisfied no one. Worse followed from the other quarter: Philoxenus of Mabbug, the able and relentless bishop of Hierapolis and leader of the non-Chalcedonian party in Syria, accused Flavian of Nestorianism — the gravest charge the age knew, implying secret denial that the Virgin bore God incarnate. Between an emperor who wanted compromise and an opposition that wanted surrender, the patriarch of Antioch was left defending a council whose defense had become, in the empire's politics, an act of rebellion.
§ Biography
The Riot of 511
The struggle for Antioch came to blood in 511. Philoxenus convinced the Miaphysites of the surrounding Syrian countryside to march on the city and compel Flavian, by force, to condemn the Council of Chalcedon. What they met was not a yielding patriarch but a defiant populace: the Chalcedonians of Antioch fell upon the attackers and slaughtered them, dumping their bodies into the Orontes, the river that framed the city. In the aftermath the monks of Flavian's own former monastery journeyed from Tilmognon to Antioch to stand in his defense against the anti-Chalcedonian party — a striking image of the monastic profession rallying behind its own son. But the victory was fatal. The sight of a patriarchal city deaf to imperial policy and red with the blood of Miaphysites drove Anastasius at last to adopt an openly Miaphysite ecclesiastical program, and when the emperor moved, both of the resisting patriarchs lost their support. Flavian and Elias had defended the council together; within a year they would fall together, victims less of each other's party than of an emperor who had finally chosen a side and could no longer tolerate shepherds who would not follow.
§ Biography
Sidon, Petra, and Death
The end was arranged by a synod. In 512 Philoxenus assembled eighty other non-Chalcedonian bishops at Sidon, with the support of Anastasius, for the formal purpose of condemning Flavian of Antioch and Elias of Jerusalem. The proceeding had no difficulty reaching its verdict, and Flavian was deposed from the see he had held for fourteen years and banished to Petra, the rock-cut capital of Arabia in the south, far from the Syrian congregations that might have rallied to him. He lived four years in that exile, dying there in 518 — the same year in which the emperor who had destroyed him also died. The deposition did not settle the empire; it unsettled it. Resentment over Flavian's fall is counted among the causes that drove Vitalian, the commander of the Danube fleet, into rebellion against Anastasius in 513, a revolt that cloaked itself in the defense of Chalcedon and nearly cost the emperor his throne. In Antioch the see passed to Severus, the non-Chalcedonian theologian, and the Chalcedonian faithful of the city learned what exile meant. Flavian's patriarchate thus ended as it had been lived: caught between an emperor's policy and a city's faith, and paying the cost of the faith.
§ Biography
Enrolled Among the Saints
The Church's verdict on Flavian was rendered quickly and, in the end, on both sides of the old division. He was soon added to the ranks of the Eastern Church's saints, and though his career had involved compromise as well as confession, the West, after some hesitation, received him into its calendar as well. The Eastern Orthodox Church commemorates him on July 20, joined with Elias of Jerusalem, the colleague with whom he had resisted the abolition of Chalcedon and shared its price. Later historians placed his fall at the hinge of the century: John Meyendorff's account of the imperial church from 450 to 680 treats the synod of Sidon and the deposition it produced as a decisive act in Anastasius's Miaphysite program, while the older Encyclopædia Britannica article, drawing on the Catholic Encyclopedia tradition, preserved the simpler memory of a Confessor banished for the council's sake. His monastery at Tilmognon, which had sent its monks to defend him in his last crisis, kept his memory among Basilian houses. He is remembered as the patriarch who held the middle ground until holding it became impossible, and who then chose the ground he would die on.
§ Biography
Timeline
- 498
Appointed patriarch of Antioch by Emperor Anastasius I after the death of Palladius, on condition of accepting the Henotikon
§ Biography
- 508
Compelled by Anastasius to sign the Henotikon
§ Biography
- 511
Miaphysite crowds stirred up by Philoxenus storm Antioch and are slaughtered by the city's Chalcedonians
§ Biography
- 512
Deposed by the synod convened at Sidon and banished to Petra
§ Biography
- 513
Vitalian's rebellion breaks out, fed by resentment over his deposition
§ Biography
- 518
Dies in exile at Petra
§ Biography
The Record
- Symbols
- Bishop's vestments·Martyr's palm
- Canonization
- Pre-congregation; enrolled posthumously among the saints of the Eastern Church, and later of the West
Prayer
Bibliography
Show 4 sources
- Fortescue, Adrian; "Elias of Jerusalem", Catholic Encyclopedia, Vol. 5, New York, Robert Appleton Company, 1909, 27 February 2014.
- Chisholm, Hugh, ed. (1911). "Flavian II.". Encyclopædia Britannica. Vol. 10 (11th ed.). Cambridge University Press. p. 484.
- "Patriarchs of Antioch 35 - Flavian II". Archdiocese of the Western USA. Retrieved 19 September 2022.
- Meyendorff, John (1989). Imperial unity and Christian divisions - The Church 450-680 A.D. The Church in history. Vol. 2. Crestwood, NY: St. Vladimir's Seminary Press. ISBN 9780881410563.
Profile text adapted from the Wikipedia article, licensed CC BY-SA 4.0.
Pray with this saint every day
Save St. Flavian II of Antioch to your favorites, read the full profile, and get feast-day reminders in the Saints app.
Get the Saints AppFree on the App Store for iPhone and iPad