c. 356 – 417·Feast January 10
St. John II of Jerusalem
Bishop of Jerusalem and Mystagogical Writer
Overview
John II (Greek: Ioannes, born c. 356) governed the church of Jerusalem from 387 until his death on 10 January 417, succeeding Cyril, who had died in 386 or 387. His thirty years at the see of the Holy City placed him at the center of the fiercest controversies of his age. Jerome, then abbot in Bethlehem, harshly questioned his authority on two occasions: first in the polemic over Origenism that erupted with Epiphanius's visit to Jerusalem in 394, and later over John's reception of Pelagius, whom a synod at Diospolis in 415 declined to condemn. John defended his faith in the Trinity and governed a church that united Greek and Jewish-Christian congregations, an achievement embodied in his consecration of the Church of Holy Zion in 394. An increasing number of modern scholars attribute to him, rather than to Cyril, the five Mystagogical Catecheses of the Jerusalem liturgy. His own writings survived only in part, scattered under other names after his death, but homilies have been restored to him in modern times. He died on 10 January 417 and is venerated by the Eastern Orthodox, Roman Catholic, and Coptic Orthodox Churches.
The Complete Life
Successor of Cyril in the Holy City
John mounted the episcopal throne of the Holy City when Cyril died in 386 or 387, and he governed the see from 387 to 417. The Jerusalem church he inherited was no longer the persecuted community of the first centuries but a city of pilgrimage, crowded with the basilicas built over the sites of the Passion and Resurrection, and its bishop occupied one of the most visible thrones in Eastern Christendom. To that see John brought scholarly habits and a taste for allegorical theology that would define both his literary legacy and his troubles. Tradition assigned to Cyril of Jerusalem the five Mystagogical Catecheses, the classic instruction given to the newly baptized on the sacraments, but an increasing number of modern scholars attribute these texts instead to John, making him a formative voice in the ancient church's teaching on worship. His episcopate spanned three decades of doctrinal storm, and the manner in which he weathered it, disputed as it was by contemporaries, has been reexamined and partly rehabilitated by the scholarship of the last two centuries. Whatever the final verdict of scholarship on the Catecheses, the picture they give of the Jerusalem liturgy at the close of the fourth century fits naturally with what is known of John's learned episcopate.
§ Life
Controversy with Jerome and Epiphanius
Twice Jerome, the abbot then living at Bethlehem, launched harsh attacks upon John's authority. The first conflict arose within the first polemic against the followers of Origen. Its immediate occasion was a visit to Jerusalem in 394 by Epiphanius, bishop of Salamis in Cyprus, who preached a pointed sermon against Origenism in the Church of the Resurrection that was understood to be aimed at John. After scenes of disorder, Epiphanius counselled Jerome and his circle to break with their bishop and, to make himself independent of John, ordained Jerome's brother Paulinian to the priesthood. John appealed to Alexandria, whose bishop Theophilus took his side, and the quarrel dragged on for about four years, marked by bitterness that left Jerome and his circle in effect excommunicate before it was stopped, perhaps by Theophilus himself. Jerome had accused John of holding a list of Origenist doctrines; John ignored the charges and gave assurances of his faith in the Trinity, though it is considered probable that he did have certain Origenist leanings. The dispute broke out afresh when Jerome attacked John's welcome for monks expelled from Nitria by Theophilus.
§ Life
The Mystagogue of Holy Zion
John's enduring title to remembrance rests on his writings. Besides the Mystagogical Catecheses that modern scholarship increasingly restores to him, his homilies have been recovered piecemeal: certain homilies in Greek, Georgian, or Armenian were returned to his name in the second half of the twentieth century, among them homilies for the feast of the Angels and for the dedication festival of the church on Holy Zion. The dedication homily, preserved in Armenian and unpublished until 1973, is the fullest surviving witness to his mind. Its central idea links the consecration of the altar to the Day of Atonement, the altar standing as the Kaporet, the mercy seat of the ancient sanctuary. In its first part the purification of the lips, drawn from Isaiah, legitimizes the description of the Holy Spirit's descent into the church building as the image of the whole Church. In its second part John unfolds a mystical typology of seven heavenly circles reached through the mediation of the Kaporet, until at the eighth circle the Holy Spirit comes as the groom of the soul. The homily weaves in more than three hundred biblical allusions, including the apocryphal 4 Ezra, and shows the influence of texts such as the Ascension of Isaiah.
§ Writings
Pelagius, Stephen, and Death
Jerome opened his second harsh attack on John in 414, this time over Pelagius. With Paulus Orosius, a Latin disciple of Augustine, at his side, Jerome ranged himself against the deacon Pelagius, whom Jerusalem received and whom the provincial synod meeting at Diospolis in 415 declined to condemn outright. A letter of Pope Innocent I censures John because Pelagians were permitted to disturb Bethlehem, urging him to keep closer watch over his diocese; the letter bears the date 417, the year in which both John and Innocent died; most likely it never reached him. Sources for the affair are more diverse here, and the charge of Arianism sometimes brought in this connection seems too simple, for the surviving evidence does not let us see the whole affair. In 415, two years before his death, John probably had a direct hand in finding the relics of Saint Stephen, the first martyr, an event of great consequence for the cult of the saints in the Holy Land. He died on 10 January 417 and was succeeded by Praulius. In the midst of these quarrels the discovery of Saint Stephen's relics must have offered the aged bishop a consoling contrast, an occasion of common joy in a reign otherwise darkened by dispute.
§ Life
Veneration in Three Traditions
The Eastern Orthodox Church numbers John among its saints and keeps his feast on March 30; the Roman Catholic Church likewise honors him, commemorating him on January 10 according to the Martyrologium Romanum of 2004. The Coptic Orthodox Church also commemorates him, on Paona 13, so that his memory is maintained across the three great ancient families of Christianity that look to Jerusalem. No formal canonization process stands behind this veneration; he belongs to the company of bishops honored from the earliest generations of the church. His reputation, however, had a troubled afterlife. On account of the damnatio memoriae that his name suffered, his writings were not generally preserved under his name, and for centuries his literary legacy was dispersed among the works of others. Only the patient philological work of modern scholars has begun to restore both the texts and the reputation of the man who governed the church of the Holy City for thirty years amid the quarrels of its most celebrated residents. That three communions long separated from one another should each preserve the memory of this contested bishop is itself a measure of how widely his sanctity was acknowledged across the Christian East and West.
§ Life
A Literary Resurrection
The restoration of John's reputation is one of the quiet achievements of twentieth-century scholarship. Gennadius of Massilia, writing in the fifth century, had already judged him an author of substance, recording that he composed a book against men who belittled his studies and followed the genius of Origen, if not his creed. For long afterwards the five Mystagogical Catecheses were read as the work of Cyril of Jerusalem, but a growing number of modern scholars now attribute them to John, which would make him among the most important witnesses to the sacramental teaching of the ancient Jerusalem church. His homily on the dedication of Holy Zion, preserved in Armenian and printed only in 1973, was identified through the studies of M. van Esbroeck, as were his homilies on the Feast of the Angels in Georgian. To him is also credited the edition of the Jerusalem liturgical lectionary that survives in an ancient Armenian version. The bishop whom Jerome attacked and whose memory was officially effaced now stands, in modern scholarship, as a mystagogue, a liturgist, and a builder of reconciliation between the Greek and Judeo-Christian communities of the Holy City.
§ Writings
Timeline
- 356
Born around this year.
§ Life
- 387
Succeeded Cyril on the episcopal throne of Jerusalem after Cyril's death in 386 or 387.
§ Life
- 394
Epiphanius, bishop of Salamis, preached a pointed sermon against Origenism at Jerusalem, widely taken as aimed at John.
§ Life
- 15 Sep 394
Consecrated the Church of Holy Zion on Mount Zion, ratifying the reconciliation of the Greek and Judeo-Christian communities.
§ Dedication of the Church of Holy Zion
- 401
The dispute with Jerome flared anew over John's welcome for Origenist monks expelled from Nitria, fifty of whom found refuge with John Chrysostom at Constantinople.
§ Life
- 414
Jerome, supported by Orosius, opened a second attack on John over his reception of the deacon Pelagius.
§ Life
- 415
A local synod at Diospolis received Pelagius without explicitly condemning him.
§ Life
- 415
Probably had a direct part in finding the relics of Saint Stephen.
§ Life
- 417
Pope Innocent I wrote a letter censuring John over the Pelagian disturbance at Bethlehem; John probably never received it.
§ Life
- 10 Jan 417
Died at Jerusalem, in the same year as Pope Innocent I.
§ Life
In Their Own Words
Wrote a book against those who disparaged his studies, in which he shows that he follows the genius of Origen not his creed.
The Record
- Major works
- Five Mystagogical Catecheses (authorship attributed to him by modern scholars)·Homily on the Dedication of the Church of Holy Zion·Homilies on the Feast of the Angels·Edition of the Jerusalem liturgical lectionary preserved in Armenian
- Canonization
- Pre-congregation; revered as a saint by the Eastern Orthodox, Roman Catholic, and Coptic Orthodox Churches since antiquity.
Prayer
Bibliography
Show 9 sources
- M. van Esbroeck, Jean II de Jérusalem. Analecta Bollandiana, Tome 102, Fasc. 1-2 (1984), p. 99-134.
- A. Piédagnel and P. Paris, Cyrille de Jérusalem, Catéchèses mystagogiques. SC 126 (1966) et 126bis (1980).
- P. Nautin, La lettre de Théophile d'Alexandrie à l'Église de Jérusalem et la réponse de Jean de Jérusalem (juin-juillet 396). Revue d'histoire ecclésiastique, 96 (1974), p. 365-394.
- F.J. Leroy, Pseudo-chrysostomica: Jean de Jérusalem. Vers une résurrection littéraire? Studia patristica, 10 (TU 107), Berlin, 1970, p. 131-136.
- Paul F. Bradshaw, The Search for the Origins of Christian Worship. 2002. ISBN 0-19-521732-2, p. 113.
- W. A. Jurgens, The Faith of the Early Fathers. 1979. ISBN 0-8146-1007-2, p. 201.
- Philip Schaff, Jerome: The Principal Works of St. Jerome. New York: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1892.
- Bargil Pixner, The Church of the Apostles found on Mount Zion. Biblical Archaeology Review 16.3, May/June 1990.
- Daniel Stökl ben Ezra, The Impact of Yom Kippur on Early Christianity: The Day of Atonement from Second Temple Judaism to the Fifth Century. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2003. ISBN 3-16-148092-9, p. 300.
Profile text adapted from the Wikipedia article, licensed CC BY-SA 4.0.
Pray with this saint every day
Save St. John II of Jerusalem to your favorites, read the full profile, and get feast-day reminders in the Saints app.
Get the Saints AppFree on the App Store for iPhone and iPad