SAINTS.APP Saint
All saints

died 347·Feast May 5

St. Maximus III of Jerusalem

Bishop of Jerusalem in the Arian Controversy

Born Unknown·🇮🇱 Israel

Overview

Maximus steered the church of Jerusalem through the pivotal middle decades of the fourth century as the third occupant of its throne to bear his name. Long before, in one of the persecutions of his youth — whether under Galerius Maximianus or under the co-emperors Diocletian and Maximian, the sources disagree — he had been tortured for the faith and so earned the title of confessor. As a priest of the Holy City he was so esteemed for character that when Macarius designed to make him bishop of Lydda the crowd would not release him. At Macarius' death Jerusalem became his charge. In 335 he attended the synod assembled at Tyre and set his hand to the censure of Athanasius which it issued; around 346, when the Alexandrian came home from exile, Maximus gathered sixteen bishops of Palestine at Jerusalem to receive him with honour, and Socrates Scholasticus notes that he gave back to Athanasius both communion and rank. For his part he pressed the claim of Jerusalem to stand level with metropolitan Caesarea, a dignity attained at last in 451. He died in 347, leaving a contested succession from which Cyril emerged.

The Complete Life

Confessor of the Holy City

Before ever he wore the mitre, Maximus had won the title of confessor. In one of the persecutions that scarred his era he was tortured for refusing to give up the Christian faith — about which emperor presided the sources divide, some naming Galerius Maximianus, others the co-emperors Diocletian and Maximian. What he endured left him honoured throughout the church of the Holy City. When peace returned he was serving as a priest at Jerusalem, cherished by the people both for the quality of his character and for the wounds his body carried. So high did he stand in their esteem that when Bishop Macarius meant to transfer him to the see of Lydda, called also Diospolis, the populace would not hear of it, insisting that a man so tried and so trusted could not be taken from them. The episode, which the historian Sozomen preserves, measures the place Maximus held in Jerusalem's affection: a confessor whose steadfastness had made him, in the eyes of the faithful, impossible to spare. Persecution had, in the idiom of the age, made him a teacher: the scars he carried preached more persuasively than any sermon, and the community that had watched him endure counted the cost of losing him and declined to pay it.

§ References

The Third of the Name

Maximus was the third bishop of Jerusalem to carry the name, after two occupants of the see in the latter half of the second century. He succeeded Macarius, the bishop under whom he had served as a priest, and assumed the government of a church that was still defining its standing among the sees of Palestine. The succession table dates his tenure from 335, while the narrative sources set his accession near 333 and his death in 347. Into his hands came the ambition that would occupy the Jerusalem church for over a hundred years: the resolve to see the city of the Resurrection ranked as an equal of the metropolitan see of Caesarea. That cause, pressed quietly under Macarius and continued under Maximus, waited long for its fulfilment; not until the Council of Chalcedon in 451 was the dignity granted. But the groundwork of the patriarchal claim was laid across these years of patient and delicate ecclesiastical diplomacy. Jerusalem in his day was a city rebuilding itself in Christian colours, its basilicas new, its pilgrimage roads busy, and its bishops increasingly conscious that the mother church of Christendom deserved a standing to match its history.

§ References

From Tyre to the Welcome of Athanasius

The fortunes of Athanasius of Alexandria ran through Maximus' episcopate like a thread. In 335 he stood among the bishops at the assembly convened at Tyre, the gathering stage-managed against the Alexandrian, and he set his signature to the condemnation it pronounced. The signature belonged to the politics of the hour; his later conduct tells another story. When Athanasius came back from exile around 346, Maximus summoned a synod of sixteen Palestinian bishops to Jerusalem to welcome him. Socrates Scholasticus records that Maximus gave the man he had once condemned both communion and rank again, and that the reconciliation profited each side: Athanasius gained allies against the Arians still pursuing him, while Maximus and the bishops of Jerusalem advanced their demand for status equal to the metropolitan see of Caesarea. The synod of 346 remains the chief monument of his episcopate — public repentance, diplomatic achievement, and a step on Jerusalem's long road to patriarchal rank, finally reached in 451. The gesture was as courageous as it was courteous. To reverse in public a condemnation one had personally endorsed required a bishop sure of his ground, and Maximus lived to see the exile depart strengthened and his own city advanced.

§ References

A Disputed Succession

The close of Maximus' life dissolved into dispute. He died in 347, and the manner of his succession became one of the tangled passages of fourth-century church history. Sozomen and Socrates relate that the Arian bishops Acacius of Caesarea and Patrophilus of Scythopolis brought about his deposition and installed Cyril in his place — an account that makes Cyril the beneficiary of an Arian intrigue. Jerome preserves a different version: Maximus, dying, had designated Heraclius as his successor, but Acacius and Cyril thrust Heraclius out and enthroned Cyril instead. Rufinus will say no more than that the ordination was in some undefined way irregular. Whichever report is true, the consequences endured: Cyril and Acacius became bitter enemies across the years that followed, contending over the Arian question and over the precedence and rights of their respective sees. The bishop who had restored Athanasius to communion left behind him a church whose own succession had turned into a battlefield. Three honest historians, three irreconcilable accounts: the disparity itself records how sharply contemporaries disagreed about a transfer of power in which doctrine and civic pride were inseparably entangled.

§ References

Feast Days of East and West

Maximus was counted among the saints by the ancient usage of the church, ages before formal canonization was thought of. The Roman Catholic Church observes his feast on May 5. The Eastern Orthodox Church keeps May 9 for him locally, while the universal Orthodox calendar honours his principal feast on August 26. His veneration across the two great traditions of East and West reflects the esteem won by his confession under torture and by his championship of the Nicene cause as a bishop. The liturgical books remember him under the title of bishop and confessor of the Holy City, the third of his name to sit upon its throne. Saints of the pre-congregation age, like Maximus, were recognised by the settled devotion of the communities that kept their memory alive, and the very plurality of his feast days testifies to how widely that devotion travelled through the churches of Palestine and beyond them. Such a plurality of commemoration is the fossil record of an early and widespread cult, carried along the trade and pilgrimage routes that converged on Jerusalem and taking root wherever travellers carried the story home.

§ References

Jerusalem on the Road to Patriarchal Rank

The see Maximus governed arrived in the end at the dignity he had pursued for it. In 451 the Council of Chalcedon raised Jerusalem to the rank its bishops had claimed since the days of Macarius and Maximus, setting it beside Caesarea and the other great metropolitan thrones. His episcopate, placed between the synod of Tyre and the return of Athanasius, marks the turning point at which Jerusalem moved from the edge of the Arian controversy toward its centre. The reconciliation of communion and rank granted to Athanasius at his gathering of sixteen Palestinian bishops became a precedent for the healing of divided churches. His successor Cyril would rank among the most celebrated teachers of the fourth century, and the feud between Cyril and Acacius of Caesarea, inherited from the irregular succession of 347, shaped Palestinian church politics for decades. Maximus stands at the hinge of all that history. What he could not have foreseen, he made possible: that within a century the bishop of Jerusalem would be addressed as patriarch, and that the fathers of 451 would write into law the equality for which he had petitioned.

§ References

Timeline

In Their Own Words

restored communion and rank
— Socrates Scholasticus, as cited in McClintock and Strong, Cyclopaedia of Biblical, Theological, and Ecclesiastical Literature, Vol. 5 (1891) · Socrates Scholasticus' description of Maximus' welcome of Athanasius at the synod of Jerusalem, c. 346

The Record

Major works
Synod of Jerusalem of sixteen Palestinian bishops in welcome of Athanasius (c. 346)
Canonization
Pre-congregation saint, venerated by the Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox churches

Prayer

Bishop Maximus, you bore in your body the marks of confession and in your hands the reconciliation of enemies. Obtain for the church of every age courage under trial, humility to correct what it has condemned in error, and patience when its own succession is disputed. Raise up shepherds who welcome the fallen with open arms, and keep the holy city of Jerusalem in your unceasing prayer. Amen.

Bibliography

Show 6 sources
  1. McClintock, John; Strong, James (1891). Cyclopaedia of Biblical, Theological, and Ecclesiastical Literature. Vol. 5. Harper & Brothers. p. 919
  2. Farmer, David Hugh; Burns, Paul (1996). Butler's Lives of the Saints: New Full Edition. Continuum International Publishing Group. p. 29. ISBN 978-0-86012-254-8
  3. Wirgman, A. Theodore (2008). The Constitutional Authority of Bishops in the Catholic Church. Fisher Press. p. 219. ISBN 978-1-4097-0111-8
  4. Bright, William (1903). The Age of the Fathers: Being Chapters in the History of the Church During the Fourth and Fifth Centuries. Longmans, Green. p. 199. ISBN 0-7905-4492-X
  5. Hanson, Richard Patrick Crosland (2005). The Search for the Christian Doctrine of God: The Arian Controversy 318-381 AD. Continuum. pp. 399-400. ISBN 978-0-567-03092-4
  6. Yarnold, Edward (2000). Cyril of Jerusalem. Routledge. p. 4. ISBN 978-0-415-19903-2

Profile text adapted from the Wikipedia article, licensed CC BY-SA 4.0.

Pray with this saint every day

Save St. Maximus III of Jerusalem to your favorites, read the full profile, and get feast-day reminders in the Saints app.

Get the Saints App

Free on the App Store for iPhone and iPad

SAINTS.APP Profile of St. Maximus III of Jerusalem

CosmoLabs