SAINTS.APP Saint
All saints

died 516

St. John II (III) of Alexandria

Coptic Patriarch and Defender of Miaphysite Faith

Born Nicius, Egypt·🇪🇬 Egypt

Overview

John II (III) of Alexandria, sometimes called John Niciota after his birthplace of Nicius in Egypt, was the thirtieth Pope of Alexandria and Patriarch of the See of St. Mark. The doubled numeral reflects the fractured memory of the Alexandrian church: the Eastern Orthodox tradition counts him as John III because it acknowledges John Talaia as John I, while the Copts, who reject Talaia, number him John II. Before his elevation he had embraced the solitary discipline of a desert monk; his consecration to the Alexandrian pontificate took place on 29 May 505, in the reign of the Emperor Anastasius I, who favored the non-Chalcedonian churches. His patriarchate unfolded alongside that of Severus of Antioch, the great champion of Miaphysitism in Syria, with whom John carried on a doctrinal correspondence on the nature of Christ. Severus wrote to him confessing one Nature and one Will after the union with flesh, and John replied with a careful profession of faith: the union of the essence of God, the trinity of His characters, and the single incarnate nature of the Word without separation, mingling, or confusion, with anathemas against all who divided or confounded what the incarnation had made one. He won renown for his numerous hagiographical compositions and sermons, and he died on 22 May 516.

The Complete Life

A Monk of the Egyptian Desert

John was born at Nicius, a town of Lower Egypt that gave him the alternative name by which history sometimes knows him: John Niciota. Of his youth the record preserves only the essential shape — he became a monk, and he chose the severest expression of that vocation, living a solitary life in the desert in the tradition of the Egyptian fathers. Egypt in the generations after Chalcedon was a land of divided loyalties, its monasteries and villages largely attached to the non-Chalcedonian faith that the Council of 451 had failed to reconcile with the Alexandrian inheritance. In that world the desert solitaries were not fugitives from theology but its guardians, and the man who emerged from solitude to rule the Alexandrian church carried with him the credibility of the ascetic life. The succession he entered was itself contested in memory: the Coptic tradition, which rejected John Talaia, counted John as the second patriarch of that name, while the Greek church of Alexandria, acknowledging Talaia, would remember him as the third. The monk of Nicius thus stepped onto a throne whose very arithmetic was a confession of faith.

§ Pope John II (III) of Alexandria

Consecrated on the Chair of St. Mark

John received his episcopal consecration for Alexandria on 29 May 505, taking up the see planted by the Evangelist Mark. He succeeded John I and would be followed in turn by Dioscorus II, holding the throne for eleven years in one of the quieter passages of a turbulent century. His election came under the Emperor Anastasius I, whose sympathies lay with the non-Chalcedonian churches and whose reign gave the patriarchs of Alexandria a measure of imperial favor they had not enjoyed under earlier rulers. The circumstances placed John among the leading hierarchs of the East at a moment when the anti-Chalcedonian communion was consolidating its theology and its leadership. Alexandria in his day was the mother church of Egypt, the seat of a patriarch whose authority ran from the Mediterranean delta deep into the Thebaid and outward to the monasteries of Scetis and Nitria. The desert monk who had sought anonymity now bore the public weight of that whole structure, and the record of his patriarchate suggests that he bore it as a teacher rather than merely an administrator, giving the church writings and sermons that would outlast the political quarrels of his reign.

§ Pope John II (III) of Alexandria

Correspondence with Severus of Antioch

The defining exchange of John's patriarchate was his correspondence with Severus of Antioch, the foremost champion of Miaphysitism in Syria and one of the great theological minds of the age. Severus addressed to John a confession concerning Christ's nature: one Nature and one Will, he wrote, belong to the Savior after His taking of flesh, without any separation, and this he held in common with Pope Cyril and Pope Dioscorus — invoking for his Christology the twin authorities of Cyril of Alexandria and Dioscorus I. In reply John bore witness to the single essence of God and the threefold character of His persons, and set out the incarnate mystery: through the eternal Son's becoming man, what is Divine and what is human had been joined into one, two natures no longer standing apart, blended, or confounded. Anathema, he declared, belonged to all who tore the two natures apart or muddled them together, to those who reduced the crucified and suffering Christ to a mere man, and to those who made His Godhead itself undergo suffering and death. Christians, he insisted, must own that the Word of God endured suffering in the very flesh He had taken to Himself — a formula that held the mystery between the two ancient errors.

§ Pope John II (III) of Alexandria

Death on 22 May 516

John governed the church of Alexandria until his death on 22 May 516, closing a patriarchate of eleven years. He died in Egypt, the land of his birth and of his see, and was buried in Saint Mark's Church, the cathedral that housed the relics of the Evangelist and the tombs of his predecessors on the Alexandrian throne. At his death the succession passed peacefully to Dioscorus II, continuing the line of non-Chalcedonian patriarchs at a moment when the emperor Anastasius still shielded them from the pressures that would return after his fall. John left behind the reputation of a teaching patriarch: renowned for his numerous hagiographical works and sermons, he enriched the literature through which the Coptic church preserved the lives of its saints and instructed its people. The quarrels of the age he left to stronger hands or to time; the confession he had drafted in answer to Severus remained among the clearest statements of what the Alexandrians believed the incarnation to mean — one incarnate nature of God the Word, suffering in the flesh He had made His own, the Godhead untouched by death even as the body He wore went down into it and rose.

§ Pope John II (III) of Alexandria

One Saint, Two Numbers

John's afterlife in the memory of the churches is unusually visible, for his very name records the schism of the fifth century. The Coptic Orthodox Church, which does not acknowledge John Talaia as a lawful patriarch, counts him as John II; the Eastern Orthodox Church, which does acknowledge Talaia, counts him as John III, and the official list of the Greek Orthodox Patriarchate of Alexandria and All Africa still enters him under that number as John III of Nicaea, holding the throne from 505 to 516. Both traditions, however, remember the same man, and the Coptic Church venerates him among its saints, the thirtieth occupant of the See of St. Mark in her reckoning. His doctrinal correspondence with Severus of Antioch passed into the inheritance of Oriental Orthodoxy as an example of how the one-nature faith was professed by its two greatest sees. His hagiographical writings and sermons served the devotional life of Egyptian Christianity for generations. And his double name remains a small monument to the truth that church divisions are carried not only in confessions but in catalogues — in the numbering of popes, where every list silently answers the question of who was, and who was not, a true bishop.

§ Pope John II (III) of Alexandria

Timeline

In Their Own Words

Jesus Christ, after the union with flesh, has become of one Nature with one Will without separation, and I believe in the same faith of Pope Cyril and Pope Dioscorus.
— Severus of Antioch, letter to Pope John II (III) of Alexandria · A message on the nature of Christ sent to John by Severus of Antioch, the champion of Miaphysitism in Syria

The Record

Major works
Hagiographical writings·Sermons·Doctrinal reply to Severus of Antioch on the nature of Christ
Canonization
Pre-congregation canonization; venerated as a saint in the Coptic Orthodox Church.

Prayer

St. John Niciota, desert monk raised to the throne of St. Mark, pray for a Church still divided over the mysteries you defended. You left solitude for strife at the call of God, and you met the finest theologians of your age with a faith both simple and exact. Obtain for teachers and patriarchs the courage to confess Christ whole and undivided, and for all the faithful the humility to receive what the apostles handed on. May your hagiographies and sermons continue to nourish those who read them, and may the peace you kept with your brother bishops flourish again among all who bear the name of Christ. Amen.

Bibliography

Show 2 sources
  1. "John III of Nicaea (505–516)". Official web site of the Greek Orthodox Patriarchate of Alexandria and All Africa. Retrieved 2011-02-07.
  2. "البابا يوأنس الثاني [Pope John II]" (in Arabic). Official website of St. Takla Haymanot's Church. Retrieved 2011-02-13.

Profile text adapted from the Wikipedia article, licensed CC BY-SA 4.0.

Pray with this saint every day

Save St. John II (III) of Alexandria to your favorites, read the full profile, and get feast-day reminders in the Saints app.

Get the Saints App

Free on the App Store for iPhone and iPad

SAINTS.APP Profile of St. John II (III) of Alexandria

CosmoLabs