died 457·Feast Unknown
St. Theodosius of Jerusalem
Anti-Chalcedonian bishop and confessor in exile
Overview
Theodosius of Jerusalem, who died in 457, stood among the foremost Palestinian monks who opposed the Council of Chalcedon, and briefly its elected bishop in the holy city. When Bishop Juvenal returned from Chalcedon in 451 having accepted the council's canons, the monks and clergy who refused to follow him persuaded him in vain to recant; on his refusal they elected Theodosius bishop in his place, and Juvenal fled. In the violence that followed, many supporters of the council died, among them Bishop Severianus of Scythopolis. From his Jerusalem seat Theodosius consecrated anti-Chalcedonian bishops across Palestine, including Peter the Iberian for the diocese of Maiuma. When Juvenal came back supported by imperial soldiers in August 453, Theodosius accepted exile rather than fight. He journeyed first to Egypt or perhaps Sinai, then toward Antioch, where he was arrested at the gates; by order of Emperor Marcian he was brought to Constantinople, refused the emperor's entreaties to accept Chalcedon, and was confined within the monastery of Saint Dios, confined through the winter to a narrow unheated cell that broke his health. Under Leo I he was placed with the anti-Chalcedonian monks of Sykai and died a few days later. His body was taken to Cyprus and buried in an anti-Chalcedonian monastery, safe from those who might have claimed his surrender.
The Complete Life
A Monk Against the Council
Theodosius belonged to the monastic world of fifth-century Palestine, and within it he rose to be numbered among the leading Christian monks of the land that opposed the Council of Chalcedon. The council of 451 had defined the union of Christ's divinity and humanity in language that many of the monks of the East could not accept, and Jerusalem's monasteries were among the strongholds of that refusal. Our knowledge of Theodosius comes almost entirely from the anti-Chalcedonian tradition, principally the works of John Rufus, who wrote the Life of Peter the Iberian and a separate account of how Theodosius was banished and died, the Narratio de obitu Theodosii Hierosolymitani, a short text surviving only in a Syriac version preserved in two manuscripts. Rufus described him as both confessor and martyr, a man whose suffering for his confession of faith had the quality of blood witness even without an executioner's blade. A complementary Syriac account by Pseudo-Zacharias Rhetor preserves the same allegiance, while the Chalcedonian side of the story comes down in Cyril of Scythopolis's biography of Euthymius the Great. That his memory required narrators on both sides of the controversy is itself the measure of how central the monk-bishop of Jerusalem became to the Christological struggles of his generation.
§ Theodosius of Jerusalem (died 457)
Bishop of the Refusers
The crisis of Theodosius's life began with the return of Bishop Juvenal to Jerusalem in 451. Juvenal had attended the Council of Chalcedon and accepted its canons, and the monks and clergy who governed themselves by the older faith gathered to persuade him to recant. When he refused, they took the momentous step of choosing Theodosius as their rival bishop, and Juvenal fled the city. The schism did not stay peaceful: bloodshed followed, and many who upheld the Council of Chalcedon were killed, Bishop Severianus of Scythopolis among them. From his contested throne Theodosius acted as the true shepherd of the anti-Chalcedonian party, consecrating bishops for its scattered communities across Palestine; among those he consecrated was Peter the Iberian for the diocese of Maiuma. The imperial answer came in August 453, when Juvenal returned to Jerusalem backed by troops, and for a brief season two active bishops contended for one city. Theodosius, whose cause commanded the monasteries but not the armies, accepted a sentence of exile and refused to fight, a renunciation of violence that his biographer Rufus regarded as intrinsic to his witness. Of the bishops he had consecrated, all were deposed except Peter, who carried the anti-Chalcedonian episcopate he had received into the generation that followed.
§ Theodosius of Jerusalem (died 457)
Exile, Prison, and Death at Constantinople
The exiled bishop's last journey led him through the geography of the whole controversy. He went first to Egypt, or perhaps to Sinai, the desert refuges of the anti-Chalcedonian monks, and then set out for Antioch, perhaps seeking the support of the famous ascetic Symeon Stylites; instead he was seized at the city gates. By order of Emperor Marcian he was conveyed to Constantinople, where the imperial policy sought not his death but his signature. When the entreaties of Marcian failed to move him toward acceptance of Chalcedon, he was confined within the monastery of Saint Dios. The abbot of that house tried persuasion, and failing, resorted to severity: Theodosius was moved into a narrow cell that was left unheated through the winter, and under that confinement he fell seriously ill. Upon Marcian's death the new emperor Leo I placed the broken bishop with the anti-Chalcedonian monks of Sykai for safekeeping, but the gesture of mercy came too late; Theodosius died only a few days later, in the year 457. His followers guarded even his remains with theological care, taking his body to Cyprus so that the Chalcedonians could not steal it and claim he had changed his mind before death; there it was buried in a monastery of his own communion. His companion Abban Romanus, the Narratio records, was recalled to Palestine after his passing.
§ Theodosius of Jerusalem (died 457)
Champion of Orthodoxy in Coptic Memory
The Coptic Orthodox Church, which rejected the Council of Chalcedon with the whole of the Oriental Orthodox communion, remembered Theodosius as a champion of orthodoxy against Chalcedonism, and his name passed into the ranks of its saints without any formal process of canonization. John Rufus had already framed the claim in his generation, describing the exiled bishop as a confessor and martyr, a man who bore in imprisonment and ill health the substance of the martyr's witness. The Coptic tradition's attachment to him expressed itself in literature as well as liturgy: two works circulating under his name testify to the authority his memory carried, even though scholars recognize both as late Coptic compositions wrongly attributed to him. His commemoration belongs to that broad company of fifth-century confessors whose sanctity was settled by the verdict of the churches that preserved their stories, and in the Coptic Church his defense of the older Christology against the council of 451 was itself the credential of sainthood. The Chalcedonian version of events, preserved in Cyril of Scythopolis, judged the same career very differently, a divergence that mirrors the division of the Churches and explains why his veneration flourished on one side of the divide rather than across it.
§ Theodosius of Jerusalem (died 457)
A Name Preserved in Books and Bones
Theodosius left no surviving school and no lasting see, yet his memory reached the present through an unusually rich trail of texts. The Narratio de obitu Theodosii Hierosolymitani of John Rufus narrates his exile and death in a short Syriac text preserved in two manuscripts; Rufus's Life of Peter the Iberian records the consecration that linked the two men; Pseudo-Zacharias Rhetor offers the complementary Syriac account; and the Chalcedonian reading of events survives in Cyril of Scythopolis's biography of Euthymius the Great. Two further writings attributed to him show the authority his name continued to exercise in Coptic circles long after his death. The first, In Honor of Victor, offers a life of the martyr Victor Stratelates, a poorly written text extolling Victor's virtues and the miracles he performed at Jerusalem, preserved in a codex of the White Monastery. The second work, The Miracles of Saint George, preaches as a homily the wonders of Saint George, clustered around the building of his shrine at Jaffa. Both are recognized as late Coptic forgeries, but the forgery itself is a kind of tribute: anonymous authors lent the name of the exiled bishop of Jerusalem to works of devotion because his reputation for orthodoxy still sanctified whatever it touched. His bones at rest in Cyprus completed the picture of a confessor whose faith, guarded jealously by his own, was never surrendered.
§ Theodosius of Jerusalem (died 457)
Timeline
- 451
The Council of Chalcedon defines its Christology, and Bishop Juvenal returns to Jerusalem having accepted its canons.
§ Theodosius of Jerusalem (died 457)
- 452
After Juvenal refuses to recant, the monks and clergy elect Theodosius bishop of Jerusalem in opposition, and Juvenal flees the city.
§ Theodosius of Jerusalem (died 457)
- Aug 453
Juvenal returns with imperial troops; Theodosius accepts a sentence of exile rather than fight, and his consecrated bishops are deposed except Peter the Iberian.
§ Theodosius of Jerusalem (died 457)
- 457
Having refused Emperor Marcian's entreaties and been imprisoned first at the monastery of Saint Dios and then with the monks of Sykai, he dies in Constantinople; his body is taken to Cyprus for burial.
§ Theodosius of Jerusalem (died 457)
The Record
- Major works
- In Honor of Victor, a biography of the martyr Victor Stratelates (a late Coptic work attributed to him)·The Miracles of Saint George, a homily on the miracles of Saint George (a late Coptic work attributed to him)
- Patron of
- remembered by the Coptic Orthodox Church as a champion of orthodoxy
- Canonization
- No formal canonization recorded; venerated in the Coptic Orthodox Church, which remembers him as a champion of orthodoxy against Chalcedonism.
Prayer
Bibliography
Show 7 sources
- Parvis, Paul (2018b). "Theodosius of Jerusalem". In Oliver Nicholson (ed.). The Oxford Dictionary of Late Antiquity. Vol. 2. Oxford University Press. p. 1486
- Orlandi, Tito (1991). "Theodosius of Jerusalem". In Aziz Suryal Atiya (ed.). The Coptic Encyclopedia. Vol. 7. New York: Macmillan Publishers. cols. 2242a-2242b
- Horn, Cornelia B. (2006). Asceticism and Christological Controversy in Fifth-Century Palestine: The Career of Peter the Iberian. Oxford University Press
- Horn, Cornelia B.; Phenix, Robert R. Jr., eds. (2008). John Rufus: The Lives of Peter the Iberian, Theodosius of Jerusalem, and the Monk Romanus. Society of Biblical Literature. ISBN 978-1-58983-200-8
- Bitton-Ashkelony, Brouria; Kofsky, Aryeh (2006). The Monastic School of Gaza. Brill. ISBN 90-04-14737-3
- Honigmann, Ernest (1950). "Juvenal of Jerusalem". Dumbarton Oaks Papers. 5: 209-279
- Butler, Alban (1821). The Lives of the Fathers, Martyrs, and Other Principal Saints. London
Profile text adapted from the Wikipedia article, licensed CC BY-SA 4.0.
Pray with this saint every day
Save St. Theodosius of Jerusalem to your favorites, read the full profile, and get feast-day reminders in the Saints app.
Get the Saints AppFree on the App Store for iPhone and iPad