SAINTS.APP Saint
All saints

late 11th century – 1154·Feast June 8

St. William of York

Twice Archbishop of York who overcame deposition and rivalry

Born York, Kingdom of England·🇬🇧 United Kingdom

Overview

William of York, born William fitzHerbert in the late eleventh century, was an English priest who served twice as Archbishop of York, separated by a rival, Henry Murdac. The son of Herbert of Winchester, chancellor and treasurer to King Henry I, William rose through the York church as prebendary of Weighton, Treasurer of York, and archdeacon of the East Riding, and served under Archbishop Thurstan, accompanying him into exile during his dispute with Henry I over the independence of York from Canterbury. Elected Archbishop of York in January 1141 after two failed earlier elections, he faced determined opposition from the Cistercian houses of Yorkshire and from Bernard of Clairvaux, who pressed the newly elected Cistercian Pope Eugene III to act against him. Suspended in 1145–1146 on a ruling that his consecration had been invalid, he was formally deposed in early 1147, a decision confirmed at the Council of Reims in 1148, and he retired to Winchester. Henry Murdac took the see in his place. After the deaths of both Murdac and Pope Eugene, William pleaded his case before the new pope, Anastasius IV, and his restoration was confirmed on 20 December 1153. Returning to York in triumph, he survived the dramatic collapse of the Ouse Bridge beneath his procession, but died on 8 June 1154, allegedly poisoned in the chalice at Mass. Miracles were reported at his tomb, and he was canonized in 1226.

The Complete Life

A Chancellor's Son in Norman York

William fitzHerbert was born in York sometime before the 1090s, though the precise date is unknown. He came from the highest circles of the Anglo-Norman administration: his father, Herbert of Winchester, also called Herbert fitzAlberic, was chancellor and treasurer to King Henry I, and held extensive landholdings in Yorkshire. Most sources give his mother as Emma, said to be a half-sister of King Stephen and of Henry of Blois, Bishop of Winchester, and a daughter born out of wedlock to Stephen II, Count of Blois; newer research, however, suggests Emma may instead have been a daughter of Hunger fitzOdin, a landholder in Dorset recorded in the Domesday survey. Whatever the exact kinship, William's family connections to the royal court shaped his whole career. He held the prebendary of Weighton in the Yorkshire diocese between 27 June 1109 and 24 February of 1114, and sometime in that same window he was appointed Treasurer of York, an office he apparently retained until his election as Archbishop. Sometime in the years from 1125 to 1133 he additionally took on the archdeaconry of the East Riding of Yorkshire. His father's wealth, power, and many Yorkshire landholdings probably helped him secure these posts while still comparatively young. Serving under Archbishop Thurstan, he became entangled in the great dispute over whether York must submit to Canterbury, accompanying his archbishop into exile on the continent and on missions to the papal court until the king's reconciliation allowed them to return to York in 1121; a ruling from Rome confirming York's independence followed in 1127.

§ Early life

Election Against the Odds

The death of Archbishop Thurstan opened a struggle for the see of York that exposed William to a decade of contention. In 1140 the cathedral chapter had elected Waltheof, but that choice was set aside when one of Waltheof's supporters made an uncanonical gift — in effect a bribe — to secure the result. Henry of Blois then attempted to place his own nephew, Henry de Sully, in the see, but Pope Innocent II refused to confirm Sully while he remained Abbot of Fécamp. William's name emerged only when a third vote was taken, in January 1141; whether he had stood in the two earlier contests is unknown. From the outset his election was contested. The Cistercian monasteries of Yorkshire objected, arguing that the Second Lateran Council of 1139 had granted religious houses within a diocese a voice in choosing their bishop, and the archdeacons of York joined the opposition. Theobald of Bec, Archbishop of Canterbury, refused to recognise the election, citing allegations of simony and of interference by King Stephen, to whom William was thought to be related. In 1143 Pope Innocent II offered a path forward: William could be confirmed if he would swear under oath that the charges brought against him were false. William took the oath; Henry of Blois, acting also as the pope's legate, pronounced him innocent, and on 26 September 1143 he was consecrated Archbishop of York.

§ Election problems

First Archbishopric and Fall

In office William pushed through a number of ecclesiastical reforms and won great popularity among the people of York, yet his position remained precarious for one formal reason: he had not received the pallium, the badge of archiepiscopal authority from the pope. The Cistercians, still adamantly opposed to him, were determined that he should never receive it. William travelled to Rome in person to press his claim, but the election of Pope Eugene III in 1145 — the first Cistercian pope — was a severe setback. Bernard of Clairvaux, the celebrated abbot and the most influential churchman of the age, exerted all his influence to secure William's suspension, sending the new pope a series of complaints: that secular powers had intruded William into the see, that the Cistercian houses were suffering oppression under him, and that his appointment of William of St. Barbara to the deanship of York had been irregular. Over the winter of 1145 to 1146 Eugene took up the case afresh, ruled William's consecration invalid, and suspended him from office, requiring him to obtain a personal refutation of the old charges from William of St. Barbara, by then Bishop of Durham. While awaiting the final decision, William stayed with his friend Roger II, King of Sicily. Hearing of the suspension, some of his supporters in York attacked Fountains Abbey and destroyed many of its buildings — an outburst that blackened his cause. Eugene formally deposed him early in 1147; the deposition received confirmation at the Council of Reims on 21 March 1148, where Henry Murdac, abbot of the Cistercian house at Fountains, was confirmed in the see. William withdrew to Winchester, the city he had left forty years earlier.

§ First archiepiscopate and deposition

Restoration and a Sudden Death

King Stephen refused to accept William's deposition and barred Henry Murdac from entering York, probably with the aim of trading recognition of Murdac for backing for the coronation of his son Eustace, whose succession he hoped to secure in his own lifetime against the rival claim of Henry of Anjou. Within a few years everything had changed: Murdac and Eugene were both dead, and William went to Rome to argue his cause before Anastasius IV, the new pope. The pope concurred, and William's reappointment to York was confirmed on 20 December 1153. His return to the city of his birth became the stuff of legend: processing in triumph across the Ouse Bridge, William saw the bridge collapse beneath the crowds — yet no one was killed, an event quickly read as a miracle and long commemorated in the iconography of the saint. His restored tenure was heartbreakingly brief. Barely a month after coming back to York, on 8 June 1154, he died — by allegation, from poison slipped into the chalice at his Mass. A clerk of William's laid the murder at the door of Osbert de Bayeux, one of the archdeacons of York; Osbert was summoned to answer the charge in the king's court, but Stephen died with the trial still pending, and the question of William's poisoning was never judicially resolved. William was buried in York Minster, the church he had governed.

§ Second archiepiscopate

Signs at the Tomb and Canonisation

Devotion to William gathered speed almost immediately after his death. Within a few months, miracles were being attributed to his intercession, and a striking occurrence sealed his reputation: when his tomb was damaged during a fire, a sweet smell rose from it, and the body within proved neither decayed nor burnt. The reports were taken seriously at the highest level. Pope Honorius III ordered an investigation into the miracles, and on 18 March 1226 he canonized William in Rome — a formal recognition, more than seventy years after his death, of the sanctity the people of York had long credited. His feast day was fixed on 8 June, the anniversary of his death, and he came to be venerated both in the Roman Catholic Church and in Anglicanism. The first shrine to William within York Minster dates from the 1220s, when his sarcophagus was sunk into the floor with a shrine structure raised above, the lid left standing proud of the pavement so that pilgrims could reach it. Though no evidence survives of large-scale pilgrimage to his shrines, the stained glass of the Minster depicts petitioners and worshippers at them, and the upper face of his sarcophagus has been worn smooth — most probably, scholars believe, by the hands of pilgrims touching it through the generations.

§ Death and sainthood

Memory in Stone, Glass, and Chapel

William's memory took durable architectural form in the city he served. A chapel dedicated to him was built in York in the later twelfth century on the northern edge of Ouse Bridge, marking the miracle of the bridge's collapse at his triumphal return in 1154; it remained a functioning chapel until 1550 and was removed only during the bridge's renovation between 1810 and 1818. Within York Minster his cult passed through a series of shrines: the sarcophagus shrine of the 1220s; the translation of 1284, funded by Bishop Bek, which moved the body to a choir shrine behind the high altar — of that shrine no trace survives; a tomb shrine of about 1330 at his original burial place in the easternmost bay of the nave; and the principal shrine of 1471–1472 near the High Altar. In 1541 the Privy Council ordered the demolition of all the shrines in the diocese of York, and William's were dismantled and buried at Precentor's Court. Fragments came to light between the eighteenth and twentieth centuries: the sarcophagus holding William's body came to light again in 1732 and once more in 1968, and the remains now rest in a shrine in the Minster crypt, while parts of the medieval shrines are kept in the Yorkshire Museum. For the eight-hundredth anniversary of his canonisation in 2026, the surviving pieces were displayed at York Minster together with a digital recreation of the lost shrine — a modern echo of the devotion that has surrounded him since 1154.

§ Shrines

Timeline

The Record

Major works
Ecclesiastical reforms as Archbishop of York·Founding influence of St William's Chapel on Ouse Bridge, York
Symbols
Crossing of the River Ouse·Archbishop's pallium·Chalice
Canonization
Canonized 18 March 1226 in Rome by Pope Honorius III.

Prayer

St. William of York, steadfast archbishop who bore unjust opposition, deprivation, and long exile without surrendering your trust in God, obtain for us patience under misunderstanding and courage in the face of powerful adversaries. You waited years for justice and returned to your flock without vengeance in your heart; teach us to forgive those who work against us. Pray for the church of York and for all shepherds whose authority is contested, that they may serve with humility, and keep us faithful through every season of trial, until we too cross safely to the other shore. Amen.

Bibliography

Show 7 sources
  1. Burton, Janet (1994). Monastic and Religious Orders in Britain: 1000–1300. Cambridge Medieval Textbooks. Cambridge UK: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-37797-8.
  2. Burton, Janet (2004). "William of York (d. 1154)". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. Oxford University Press. doi: 10.1093/ref:odnb/9606.
  3. Crouch, David (2000). The Reign of King Stephen: 1135–1154. New York: Longman. ISBN 0-582-22657-0.
  4. Davis, R. H. C. (1990). King Stephen 1135–1154 (Third ed.). New York: Longman. ISBN 0-582-04000-0.
  5. Norton, Christopher (2006). St William of York. York, UK: York Medieval Press. ISBN 1-903153-17-4.
  6. Wilson, Christopher (1977). The Shrines of St William of York. Yorkshire Museum.
  7. Knowles, David (1936). "The Case of Saint William of York". Cambridge Historical Journal. 5 (2): 162–177. doi: 10.1017/S1474691300001311.

Profile text adapted from the Wikipedia article, licensed CC BY-SA 4.0.

Pray with this saint every day

Save St. William of York to your favorites, read the full profile, and get feast-day reminders in the Saints app.

Get the Saints App

Free on the App Store for iPhone and iPad

SAINTS.APP Profile of St. William of York

CosmoLabs